查看完整版本: raptor id, please

raptor id, please

is it Crested Serpent Eagle???
taken today at KFBG, near Kun Yam Shan, thank you very much!!!

[img]http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3656/3600355806_17e1b931d1_o.jpg[/img]


[img]http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2457/3599544513_3f6d6da93e_o.jpg[/img]


[img]http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3327/3600355680_81a82bc042_o.jpg[/img]

Hi Maria, we might have seen this bird too since I was birdwatching in Tai Mo Shan today morning!  My friend and I saw 1 Bonelli's eagle and 2 crested serpent eagles flying to the direction to Shek Kong/Kun Yam Shan.  The former and 1 of the latter had a very bad shape - severe loss of feathers.  The crested serpent eagle was even chased by a black kite to leave its 'zone'.  From the underwing converts, it's not like a crested serpent eagle.  So I think it's a Bonelli's eagle?

Would more experienced birders please comment? (I could not think of any other possibilities...of course this bird may not be the one we've seen!) 3551a50445

[[i] Last edited by thinfor at 6/06/2009 18:40 [/i]]

oh....I just think it is Crested Goshawk3551sweat445

Yes, you're right.  It must be another bird since it doesn't look like a raptor with an eagle size (It doesn't look like a Bonelli's eagle neither according to the prev photos posted).  I linked the 2 birds since their feather loss were quite similar but indeed from my memory the eagle I've seen had a even more worn tail.

It's definitely a kind of goshawk.  Thanks! 3551smile445

[[i] Last edited by thinfor at 6/06/2009 20:25 [/i]]

thanks peter & manson!!  3551875328cc445

I agree that this is a Crested Goshawk - probably a first-summer bird showing a lot of wing moult.

thanks john for confirming the id!!35515fc0f220445