Thread
Print

I D please.

I D please.

Mai Po Sept.23 2010
Is it a Pied Harrier 鵲鷂. Sorry for the bad resolution as the photo was taken in quite a distance. Thanks...

Attachment

DSC_4021A.jpg (159.38 KB)

27/09/2010 19:47

DSC_4021A.jpg

TOP

This is a black Kite
I am just an inexperienced birder/ birdwatcher/ twitcher/ photographer with no long lens.

TOP

thanks a lot...暉仔

TOP

A pied harrier?

Dear Stonechat

Though your photo is a bit blurred, it nevertheless affords identification which I am of the
opinion that it is an Eastern marsh harrier for the following reasons:

Structurally, it is wide-winged and proportionally the tail looks a bit short
for a pied.

It is probably a juvenile male for showing no pale rump and and no sharp underwing primary base
contrast which for a pied should be whitish with black towards tips instead of buffy with black
outer part.

So I takes it to be a Eastern marsh harrier.

S L Tai

TOP

correction of judgement

Dear Stonechat

I'm a bit misled by your thinking that it's a harrier.

That tail tells everything. The bill shape and upper wing pattern also point towards it being
a black-eared kite.

I've just realized how new-handed I'm at photographic identification of birds!

S L Tai

TOP

thanks a lot...tsheunglai...

TOP

Thread