Subject: I D please！ [Print This Page] Author: Mon Time: 1/03/2010 21:43 Subject: I D please！
2010/2/27
Hong Kong Wetland Park
Common Snipe or Pintail Snipe?
[img][/img] Author: HFCheung Time: 1/03/2010 22:15
Common. The pattern on the back is useful to identify them.
HF Cheung Author: Mon Time: 2/03/2010 20:44
多謝輝哥！Author: ajohn Time: 3/03/2010 10:10
I would say this looks more like Pintail/Swinhoe's.
The pale fringes on the upperparts are only obvious on the inner scapulars, making the upperparts less contrasting than usual on Common (which usually has 4 obvious stripes down the back, whereas this bird only has 2)
The head pattern is also more suggestive of Pintail/Swinhoe's in my opinion - less contrasting than Common, with a less obvious cheek bar than in that species.
Also the bird looks darker underneath than I usually associate with Common.
But I admit that I often find snipe difficult to ID on the ground.
I'm not sure how relevant this is, but in my experience, Pintail/Swinhoe's is more often in intertidal/brackish than freshwater habitats in winter (at least at Kam Tin), although Common can be in either habitat. This bird looks to be in intertidal mangrove edge.
Welcome to HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 (http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/)
[/img] 