Subject: Revised HK List [Print This Page] Author: cgeoff Time: 3/07/2010 12:10 Subject: Revised HK List
Although the basis of the recent revision of the HK List has been agreed, the work required to finalise it has not quite been completed. This is mainly due to the fact that, in addition to adopting a new taxonomy and nomenclature, we have also adopted a new system of categorisation.
Finalising species' names has involved consideration not only of those for which we feel a different English name is more appropriate, but also amendments to the system of hyphenation used, which the RC feels is problematic for a few species. These have now been implemented.
However, the new categorisation system (posted previously on this Forum) has required reviews of the status of a small number of species to be carried out (primarily due to the loss of the old Category B). These have not yet been completed, and the following remain: Chestnut-tailed Starling, Pale Blue Flycatcher, Chinese Blue Flycatcher, Grey-necked Bunting, Eurasian Collared Dove and Azure-winged Magpie.
Rather than waiting for these to be completed (at the next RC meeting scheduled for 1st Sept), we are posting the new list now. Please note the numbers are provisional, and will be finalised once the reviews have been completed. HK List (IOC) Cat I-II 20100706.pdf (209.07 KB)
Any comments on the list or the format in which it is presented are most welcome.
Finally, a warning that the upcoming HKBR will not be based on this revised list. It is too far along the road to final publication. However, the 2007-08 Report will.
Regards,
GeoffC
RC Chairman
Attachment: HK List (IOC) Cat III 20100703.pdf (5/07/2010 10:01, 94.65 KB) / Download count 1193 http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/attachment.php?aid=6839
Thanks to Geoff and Record Committee members. Producing the most-updated HK list is an important task of HKBWS. The list with Chinese name has been uploaded in the HK List section of the discussion forum.
HF Cheung Author: gary Time: 5/07/2010 15:26
Thank you for RC's effort, it's a not easy and never ending task.
Just have one observation: Pomarine Skua, Parasitic Jaeger and Long-tailed Jaeger are all from same genus Stercorarius but different in naming - Skua/Jaeger. Is that any meaning for not being consistent? Author: HFCheung Time: 5/07/2010 17:59
Some observation of the new HK list:
1. Category
Old New
A I
B I
C IIA
D IIB
2. New English name (obvious changes only)
Number New English Name Old English Name Ch. Name
17 Indian Spot-billed Duck Indian Spotbill 印缅斑嘴鸭
18 Chinese Spot-billed Duck Chinese Spotbill 中華斑嘴鴨
23 Eurasian Teal Common Teal 綠翅鴨
30 White-winged Scoter Velvet Scoter 斑臉海番鴨
31 American Scoter Black Scoter 黑海番鴨
52 Eurasian Bittern Great Bittern 大麻鳽
54 Von Schrenck's Bittern Schrenck’s Bittern 紫背葦鳽
62 Eastern Cattle Egret Cattle Egret 牛背鷺
65 Eastern Great Egret Great Egret 大白鷺
68 Pacific Reef Heron Pacific Reef Egret 岩鷺
79 Western Osprey Osprey 鶚
91 Chinese Sparrowhawk Chinese Goshawk 赤腹鷹
96 Eastern Buzzard Common Buzzard 普通鵟
99 Eastern Imperial Eagle Imperial Eagle 白肩鵰
123 Great Stone-curlew Great Thick-knee 大石鴴
151 Eastern Curlew Far Eastern Curlew 紅腰杓鷸
194 Caspian Gull Yellow-legged Gull 黃腳銀鷗
209 Pomarine Skua Pomarine Jaeger 中賊鷗
214 Domestic Pigeon Rock Dove 原鴿
219 Common Emerald Dove Emerald Dove 綠翅金鳩
228 Asian Koel Common Koel 噪鵑
230 Square-tailed Drongo Cuckoo Drongo Cuckoo 烏鵑
234 Lesser Cuckoo Asian Lesser Cuckoo 小杜鵑
236 Oriental Cuckoo Horsfield's Cuckoo 霍氏[中]杜鵑
254 House Swift Little Swift 小白腰雨燕
255 Oriental Dollarbird Dollarbird 三寶鳥
285 White-bellied Erpornis White-bellied Yuhina 白腹鳳鶥
294 Red-billed Blue Magpie Blue Magpie 紅嘴藍鵲
296 Eurasian Magpie Common Magpie 喜鵲
316 Grey-throated Martin Plain Martin 褐喉沙燕
319 Common House Martin Northern House Martin 白腹毛脚燕
322 Asian Stubtail Asian Stubtail Warbler 鱗頭樹鶯
324 Manchurian Bush Warbler Japanese Bush Warbler 日本樹鶯
325 Brown-flanked Bush Warbler Brownish-flanked Bush Warbler 強腳樹鶯
329 Common Chiffchaff Chiffchaff 嘰喳柳莺
338 Two-barred Warbler Greenish Warbler 暗綠柳鶯
365 Golden-headed Cisticola Bright-capped Cisticola 金頭扇尾鶯
369 Rufous-rumped Grassbird Large Grass Warbler 大草鶯
377 Chinese Hwamei Hwamei 畫眉
379 Silver-eared Leiothrix Silver-eared Mesia 銀耳相思鳥
382 Chesnut-collared Yuhina Striated Yuhina 栗耳鳳鶥
393 Daurian Starling Purple-backed Starling 北椋鳥
397 Rosy Starling Rose-coloured Starling 粉紅椋鳥
402 White's Thrush Scaly Thrush 虎斑地鶇
424 Plumbeous Water Redstart Plumbeous Redstart 紅尾水鴝
426 Siberian Stonechat Common Stonechat 黑喉石(即鳥)
450 Chinese Blue Flycatcher Blue-throated Flycatcher 藍喉仙鶲
453 Grey-headed Canary-Flycatcher Grey-headed Flycatcher 方尾鶲
456 Fire-breasted Flowerpecker Buff-bellied Flowerpecker 紅胸啄花鳥
467 Eastern Yellow Wagtail Yellow Wagtail 黃鶺鴒
484 Chinese Grosbeak Yellow-billed Grosbeak 黑尾蠟嘴雀
450 Chinese Blue Flycatcher Cyornis glaucicomans 中華仙鶲 is not the same species as Blue-throated Flycatcher Cyornis rubeculoides 藍喉仙鶲. It is not just a change of name, but a review of their taxonomical status. Author: cgeoff Time: 6/07/2010 15:13
One error has been pointed out to me, and that concerns Fork-tailed Drongo Cuckoo, which had the incorrect English and scientific name. This is now corrected, and the revised list will be uploaded soon.
GeoffC Author: HKBWS WY Time: 6/07/2010 16:23
File updated. Author: gary Time: 9/07/2010 22:26
May I know does the HK list strictly or selectively follow IOC world list? Just found that Eurasian Black Vulture is not found in the IOC list, which instead adopt the name Cinereous Vulture.
Also, Christmas Frigatebird in IOC list but Christmas Island Frigatebird in HK list.
Gary
[ Last edited by gary at 9/07/2010 22:34 ] Author: cgeoff Time: 10/07/2010 10:24
The taxonomy is adopted in its entirety, while the English names are largely the same as the IOC. Where there was strong feeling that a particular English name was inappropriate (partly based on comments received when the List was initially uploaded to the Forum), the RC adopted a different one.
This decision and the list of departures from the IOC List was posted on the Forum and comments invited.
Regds,
GeoffC
Welcome to HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 (http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/)