little ringed plover? Author: kkchang168 Time: 2/06/2013 21:45
No, I think it is Lesser Sand Plover. For oriental plover, there are blank border below the chestnut breast. For Little Ringed Plover, there should have a complete white neck ring. Author: LIJO Time: 2/06/2013 21:50
Should it be Greater Sand Plover? Author: ajohn Time: 3/06/2013 08:14
Oriental Plover would typically have longer and paler legs, a long slim bill and would probably appear whiter on the head. The dark mask and lack of a white band around the rear of the neck confirm these as sand plovers.
The bird on the right is a Lesser Sand Plover (subspecies either mongolus or stegmanni) - note that the bill is rather short and blunt, the head is rounded and there are dark markings along the flanks. There is very little breeding plumage so it is probably a first-summer bird (possibly a female, but I think even too dull for that).
The bird on the left is a Greater Sand Plover - in comparison the bill is longer and heavier, and the head is squarer. Again, breeding plumage is not far advanced and this is probably a first-summer bird.
[ Last edited by ajohn at 3/06/2013 08:16 ] Author: kkchang168 Time: 5/06/2013 15:54
Thanks John, I did not notice the bill of the left one and the size of it is similar to the right hand side, so I think both of them are Lesser Sand Plover (as Greater Sand Plover is larger than Lesser Sand Plover). But after you mention the bill structure, it is clear that the left one is Greater Sand Plover. In that case, size of Greater Sand Plover may not bigger than Lesser Sand Plover? Of course, I know that this is not the most important element to distinguish the two, but I think it is a quite easy method to distinguish the two in the field. Author: ajohn Time: 6/06/2013 09:06
I think the bird on the left is slightly larger than that on the right. The bird on the right is more alert, with the neck stretched slgihtly, making it look bigger.
But it is true that size should not be relied on entirely in these species. Although Lesser averages smaller than Greater, measurements show that there is overlap in size between Greater sand Plover and mongolus Lesser Sand Plovers. atrifrons Lesser Sand Plovers are slightly smaller and probably do not overlap in size with Greater Sand Plover. In both species males are larger than females.
Size can be a difficult feature to judge in the field, especially if you do not have other birds for direct comparison. It is better not to rely only on size, but to also look at structural and plumage features.
Welcome to HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 (http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/)
Image Attachment: IMG_9818.jpg (2/06/2013 14:24, 74.24 KB) / Download count 354