Board logo

Subject: [Hong Kong] ID please [Print This Page]

Author: Hung    Time: 18/10/2013 23:12     Subject: ID please

18/10/2013 Tai Po Kau
Thank you

Author: John Holmes    Time: 19/10/2013 13:15     Subject: Mystery raptor

Looks good for Mountain Hawk Eagle (Nisaetus nipalensis) to me, and -if so- a VERY good record !
Author: subbuteo    Time: 19/10/2013 16:34

This picture is fairly similar.   Also this picture.  

Fantastic bird, well done!  Glad John knew what it was as I was at a loss.

Dylan

[ Last edited by subbuteo at 19/10/2013 17:07 ]
Author: ddavid    Time: 19/10/2013 19:09

I was just wondering - the Tai Po Kau bird shows 6 primary "fingers". The picture in Subbuteo's first link above shows 7 primary "fingers".   

Is perhaps 6 primary "fingers" more indicative of Oriental Honey-buzzard?
See
http://orientalbirdimages.org/bi ... p;Bird_Family_ID=96

David

[ Last edited by ddavid at 19/10/2013 19:11 ]
Author: tsheunglai    Time: 19/10/2013 20:52

I incline to think it's a honey-buzzard.

First, the wing's not wide enough in mide part of wing.

The bill and head too small for a hawk eagle. The shape of the bill also typical of a buzzard's.

S L Tai
Author: John Holmes    Time: 20/10/2013 07:16     Subject: Tai Po Kau raptor

Dylan and Dave, - Thanks for the links.... I take your point, Dave, about the number of primary "fingers" and, Mr TAI I note your comments, too.

I think that the underparts on the bird in the photo look quite heavily barred on wings and tail, and the structure, to me, seems right for a larger bird.

But OHB is statistically more likely, if we have a shot showing the pair of bars near the base of the tail, that should nail the ID...

HUNG... do you have any more photos of this bird ?
Author: Hung    Time: 20/10/2013 12:21

I'm sorry that I only got 1 photo on it

The uncropped one
Author: ajohn    Time: 20/10/2013 15:14

I think if you zoom in on the photo in the first post, you can see the tail pattern of an Oriental Honey-buzzard, with bars towards the base and at the tip, and a large pale space between. Overall similar to this bird:
http://orientalbirdimages.org/se ... _ID=&pagesize=1




Welcome to HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 (http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/) Powered by Discuz! 6.0.0