Subject: Po Toi Seawatch Year 2022 [Print This Page] Author: badesc Time: 3/01/2023 09:32 Subject: Po Toi Seawatch Year 2022
Introduction
This is a review of the year 2022 of seawatching from Nam Kok Tsui on Po Toi Island. Regular surveys were mostly done in spring and to a lesser degree (early) autumn.
General
Let’s look at some general items first.
• Firstly, there were no seawatching surveys during the year in November and December. I therefore would be careful with drawing too many conclusions, as it might simply be due to how much – if at all – we seawatched during any given month.
• We seawatched for a total of 630 hours, more than the 492 hours and 25 minutes in 2021.
• We watched the most in May (128 hours and 55 minutes), followed by March and September.
• The most birdy month by far was May, with 11,924 migrant birds counted. Last year, that was September, with 11,101 migrating bords counted. The difference between 2021 and 2022 is that we watched more in May 2022 than we watched in September 2021. The second busiest month in 2022 was September. It seems that May and September are the best months when it comes to the number of migrating birds off Po Toi.
• We counted a total of 33,133 migrating birds*, almost 50% more than in 2021 (22,354). This is mainly related to more seawatching, and maybe some improvement in planning and technique. The one thing that is sure, is that tens of thousands of migrants pass Po Toi every year.
• We identified 84 migrating species during the year.
Here is the table from Trektellen with all the numbers:
* The total number on the above table of Trektellen includes 62 dolphins. The counts also include some potential double counts of Streaked Shearwater, and Flesh-footed Shearwater (same individual seen on two subsequent days and counted as two on Trektellen).
For reports on every survey, please consult these posts:
I believe we encountered just two real rarities/vagrants: Flesh-footed Shearwater (first record for Hong Kong, accepted by the Records Committee) and Masked Booby (second record for Hong Kong – and Po Toi –, under review by the Records Committee). But this is a personal opinion. I refer to the yet to be published HKBWS Bird Report 2022 for a more ‘official’ stance.
You could argue that we also encountered a few Po Toi rarities, which are otherwise more common elsewhere in Hong Kong, like Black-winged Stilt, Pied Avocet (first record) and Little Ringed Plover.
Weather
Weather and birds remained as complex and comprehensive as in the previous year. Be out there seawatching during spring and autumn migrating periods, regardless of the weather, is most important to see good species and/or numbers.
Chaba was very fruitful, with two Bulwer’s Petrels and high counts for Hong Kong of Red-footed Booby and Sooty Tern, while Mulan was not, with just one Red-footed Booby.
Cold fronts
One cold front that had a profound impact on migrants occurred on 1 May. We noted an exceptionally fall of landbirds, such as swifts, Browns Shrikes and Chinese Sparrowhawks.
This is the full list of all migrant species that we saw and counted. In case there’s an accompanied chart when relevant, I posted one for 2022 only (total counted per day) and a second for both 2021 and 2022 (total number per standard week). These charts often say more than a thousand words, so the text is usually kept short.
Black SwanCygnus atratus
One record: a single bird flying northeast on 20 May. This is a Category III species (escaped or released from captivity), but a first for Po Toi.
Ducks
Some species of duck were unrecorded, as they were seen in late autumn and December during seawatching in 2021. This year, we did not do any seawatching during this time.
duck spec.
Unidentified ducks appeared in January, March, early October, and with a peak in September. I believe most of them were Garganey. A total of 303 were counted.
Garganey Spatula querquedula
With some more seawatching in early spring, small numbers were seen during the end of March and early April. Many more were counted in September, which seems to be the peak month for them. With a combination of very good conditions and birds flying much closer than usual, a record number of 1,007 were counted on 20 September. This was also the highest count for Hong Kong, ever.
There is a strong indication that the vast majority of ducks that pass Po Toi, are Garganeys.
Eurasian TealAnas crecca
Only three Eurasian Teals were identifiable with certainty, on 18 February.
Tufted DuckAythya fuligula
Only one record: one on 16 March.
Himalayan SwiftletAerodramus brevirostris
Two records, all in September (like in 2021): two on 9 September and one on 21 September.
needletail spec.Hirundapus spec.
One record: six on 1 May.
Pacific SwiftApus pacificus
Many more were seen in 2022 than in 2021, with a very clear peak in spring (April and May). Highest count 30 on 1 May.
Same as Pacific Swift: much more were seen in 2022, but only from mid-April to early May (note that there were no surveys in November 2022, a month in which the species was seen in 2021). Highest count 62 on 1 May.
Rock DoveColumba livia
One record: one on 7 September.
wader spec.
The vast majority of waders could not be identified. The reasons being too far, flying too fast and sometimes in bad lighting conditions. Most probably, a wide variety of wader species pass Po Toi, mainly in spring.
The total number of wader spec. (640), small wader spec. (28) and large wader spec. (6) amount to 674. The chart below shows wader spec. records, with an obvious peak in the spring months.
Not seen in 2021, but seven on 16 April and two on 17 April 2022.
Eurasian CurlewNumenius arquata
Just three records: two on 31 March, three on 17 April and six on 22 September.
Ruddy TurnstoneArenaria interpres
There were one or two Ruddy Turnstones present near the watchpoint in early May, only one flew by as a migrant on 26 April.
Great KnotCalidris tenuirostris
Not seen in 2021 and only one record in 2022: 16 on 30 March.
Sharp-tailed SandpiperCalidris acuminata
Just two singles were identifiable, on 30 March and on 2 May.
Curlew SandpiperCalidris ferruginea
One record: six on 30 March.
Red-necked StintCalidris ruficollis
A total of 76 individuals counted, between 30 March and 4 May. Highest count 50 on 18 April.
Dunlin Calidris alpina
Could be more common, but unidentifiable. Only one record of six on 31 March.
Terek SandpiperXenus cinereus
Yet another wader that wasn’t recorded in 2021. 26 were seen on 4 May in 2022.
Red-necked PhalaropePhalaropus lobatus
A total of 5,788 have been counted, the vast majority in spring. Highest counts were 821 on 7 May and 601 on 30 March. The high count in May is exceptionally for that month.
In 2021, it was a species that occurred mainly in November and December, two months during which we did not do any surveys in 2022. Fewer individuals, less than ten on all but one day, were counted in January to March, with the highest count 47 on 15 March.
A total of 629 birds were counted. A gull that appears to be most regular in January and February. Highest count 128 on 19 February. One (adult) on 1 July is exceptional. Earliest individual for the second half of the year was seen on 11 August.
I still believe the vast majority of unidentified terns are Common Terns and Aleutian Terns. But as is illustrated under both species – which could be identified with certainty – in this review, their peak is in spring, not in autumn. Yet, this should not be the conclusion, as the peak numbers of unidentified – and likely Common and Aleutian – terns actually occur in autumn. It remains one of the unanswered questions of bird migration off Po Toi: what species of terns move through during autumn, mainly September? Frustrating, as it is by far the most common group of birds that we see here.
A total of 272 individuals were counted. First record on 29 March, last one on 21 September. Highest count was 62 on 26 April.
And, interestingly, most appeared in spring, not in autumn as in 2021. It’s a good illustration to be careful with some quick conclusions, as different results can depend on when and how often seawatching surveys have been undertaken.
From our surveys in 2021, and illustrated on the below graph (bottom one), the vast majority of Caspian Terns occur in November. As there were no surveys in November 2022 we counted only 16 Caspian Terns, compared to 263 in 2021. Highest count was just eight in 27 February.
2022 was an even better year for this species than 2021, with a total of 2,105 counted, compared to 1,108. It’s one of the more regular migrant terns, which occurs from March to October, with September being the peak month. First record on 16 March, last one on 1 October. We counted a new record high for Hong Kong, with 201 individuals on 21 September.
This species seems to peak in spring. Because we did more surveys in spring in 2022, the numbers (781) were more than tenfold compared to those of 2021 (70). First record on 30 March, last one on 8 September. Highest count was 180 on 18 April.
Another species with a tenfold in numbers if we compare 2021 (142) to 2022 (1,434). And that is virtually certain mostly due to more surveys in spring last year. First record on 10 April, last one on 1 October. Highest count 312 on 7 May.
Let me repeat what I wrote in the 2021 review. A bit of a tricky species to count, as it is also a local breeder and these birds might fly along the same route, to feed out at sea, as migrants do. So counting locals for migrants cannot be excluded. The graph below nevertheless showed our attempt to only count what we believe to be migrants. And then, as in 2021, we see two peaks, in May and in August. A total of 2,063 individuals was counted, with highest counts of 248 on 8 May, just four days apart from the highest count in 2021 (12 May). First record on 15 April, last one on 21 September.
Three records of five juveniles, all seen during the passage of Tropical Cyclone Chaba: one on 1 July, three on 3 July and one on 4 July. The three individuals were a new high count for Hong Kong.
Roseate TernSterna dougallii
Local breeder. A species which we encountered in far greater numbers in 2021 (203) than in 2022 (61). First record on 5 May, last one on 20 August. Highest count 18 on 20 August. The peak for this species seems to occur during a limited time between mid to late August.
Also a local breeder, of which the graph only shows counts of birds of which we believe were migrants. A total of 92 birds were counted. Obviously, a peak in spring, with the highest count of 27 on 5 May. First record on 3 April, last one on 21 May. Surprisingly, no autumn records in 2022.
A total of 3,700 were counted in 2022, much more than the 1,176 in 2021. Again, the opposite of the previous year: the peak appeared in spring, not in autumn. And again, that’s mainly because of more spring surveys in 2022 than in 2021. But note that we’re not sure if the peak really is in spring, as there are a large number of unidentified terns seen in autumn of which many might be Common Terns. Highest counts 456 on 5 May and 447 on 4 May. First record on 16 March, last one on 1 October.
Another tern species of which we had higher counts in 2022 (311) than in 2021 (88). Highest count 92 on 1 May. First record on 29 March, last one on 30 June. So, no autumn sightings in 2022.
A total of 1,460 was counted (574 in 2021). Highest count 336 on 7 May. First record on 15 April, last one on 30 June. None seen in autumn, in contrast to 2021. But this really seems a migrant that mainly occurs in spring/May.
With surveys in early spring, we counted much more Pomarine Jaegers in 2022 (46) than in 2021 (2). They migrate pass Po Toi much earlier than Parasitic Jaegers. First record on 16 February, last one on 18 April. Highest count 23 on 18 February.
No less than a total of 211 were counted. Highest count 43 on 25 April, which was a new high count for Hong Kong. First record on 21 March, last one on 30 September.
We didn’t record any Ancient Murrelets in 2021, but a total of 78 in 2022. The reason is probably twofold: firstly, they might just be much scarcer in November and December, and secondly there were no surveys in 2021 until 29 March. In 2022, we record almost all Ancient Murrelets from January to March and only five on one day in early April. Highest count was 14 on 13 March, a new high count for Hong Kong. First record on 11 January, last one on 10 April.
There were two records of Swinhoe’s Storm Petrels Hydrobates monorhis in 2021, but none in 2022. However, we did see two unidentified storm petrels that most likely were this species: one sitting on the water on 6 May and one during Tropical Cyclone Chaba on 2 July. Hence, I still belief this is an annual visitor to Hong Kong waters and not a vagrant.
shearwater spec.Ardenna spec.
One record: a single bird on 30 September, most likely Wedge-tailed Shearwater.
Streaked ShearwaterCalonectris leucomelas
2022 was a truly unprecedented year for this species. Yet, the question remains if this was an aberrant year or a more normal one. A total of 1,277 have been submitted to Trektellen, but the exact number of individuals is most probably somewhat lower. There were two periods, 17 to 19 February and 20 to 22 March, during which hundreds were seen off Po Toi but same birds might have been counted on different days. I believe the true number, conservatively estimated, would be around 1,000 for the year. Highest count was 479 on 21 March, by far the highest count for Hong Kong, ever. First record on 17 February, last one on 2 July.
With more surveys in spring, we recorded a total of 110 in 2022, compared to 48 in 2021. Highest count 18 on 7 May, a new high count for Hong Kong. First record on 18 April, last one on 3 July. The peak is clearly in May, but note that there are also Hong Kong records in April, June, July, September and December.
One record: a single bird on 20 and 21 March. Accepted by the Records Committee as the first record for Hong Kong.
Bulwer's PetrelBulweria bulwerii
Three records: singles on 20 May, 2 and 3 July. We’ve seen two Bulwer’s Petrels in 2021 and three in 2022. Plus, Robert Hackel and I saw one from a boat in southern waters on 29 April. Note that we also saw two single all-dark tubenoses from Po Toi in both 2021 and 2022, which were very likely this species. There also have been records in Hong Kong adjacent waters, like two individuals seen and photographed by Shashika Bandara from a ship in mid-April 2022. And a single Bulwer’s was seen by Graham Talbot on 13 October 2021 from Cape D’Aquilar. I believe it all indicates quite clearly that Bulwer’s Petrel is indeed not a rarity and certainly not a vagrant to Hong Kong waters, but much more likely an annual, scarce passage migrant in (mainly) spring and autumn, and a storm-driven visitor in summer months. Our records on 29 April and 20 May were during calm weather, so we even do not need typhoons or storms to bring them to Hong Kong. Although, in any season (especially in summer), storms might help, of course.
Lesser FrigatebirdFregata ariel
On record of a non-migrating bird over Nam Kok Tsui on 19 June.
Masked BoobySula dactylatra
One record: a singe adult on 6 May. If accepted, it would be the second record for Hong Kong (and Po Toi). The bird was also seen by others and also in Chinese waters. But when we first saw it from Po Toi, to the west-southwest of the watchpoint, it was well to the north of the red lightboat and thus well in Hong Kong territory.
Red-footed BoobySula sula
2022 seemed like a good year, with no less than ten Red-footed Boobies seen. They were seen during storms, but also in the absence of a storm. Highest count five during Tropical Cyclone Chaba, a new high count for Hong Kong.
2022 turned out to be a great year for Brown Boobies as well, with no less than 15 seen. There have never been so many records in Hong Kong. Prior to 2022 there were mostly single records per year and not annual. It’s unclear to me whether 2022 was exceptional or just the result of more surveys. Highest counts two on 29 March and 6 May. First record on 29 March, last one on 5 July.
The families here are both Egretta and Bubulcus. 357 unidentifiable egrets passed Po Toi, and, like in 2021, mainly in September. Highest count 111 on 10 September.
2 unidentified herons, either Grey or Purple, were seen on 30 October.
Black-crowned Night HeronNycticorax nycticorax
One record: two on 17 April.
Striated HeronButorides striata
Two records: singles on 4 May and 21 September.
Chinese Pond HeronArdeola bacchus
Only three records in 2022: one on 4 May, 3 on 15 May and one on 21 August.
Eastern Cattle EgretBubulcus coromandus
More than twice as much counted in 2022 (386) than in 2021 (150). Highest count 132 on 2 May. First record on 21 March, last one on 30 September. The peak indeed occurs in May, but note the large number of unidentified egrets (see above), with a peak in September, of which many could be Eastern Cattle Egrets.