Subject: Warbler id. Thanks [Print This Page] Author: Allen Time: 24/10/2007 23:33 Subject: Warbler id. Thanks
05/11/2006
Po Toi
Sorry for these are the old photos of last year.
Please help to identify the warbler.
Thanks in advance.
Author: gary Time: 25/10/2007 17:14
Hi Allen,
The heavily streaked breasted is unusual for Dusky Warbler. You may go for Raddes Warbler or Yellow-streaked Warbler.
I have no experience on Yellow-streaked warbler and don't know if Raddes can be so streaked on its breast. However, the diffused front part of eyebrow and thick bill favour Raddes for me.
No matter which one, it's a clear photo to show the features of the bird. Remember to submit the photo to Photo Guide committe when it confirmed.
Gary Author: Allen Time: 25/10/2007 23:30
Hi Gary,
Thank you very much.
Allen Author: lpaul Time: 26/10/2007 09:41
This is a Dusky Warbler. The streaking is unusual but not atypical of that species. The features which eliminate Radde's and Yellow-streaked are the fine bill (sorry Gary!) but also the dark legs (pale orange-flesh in Radde's and Yellow-streaked). Also the cold grey brown upperparts are wrong as they would be obviously olive toned in the other two. Author: Allen Time: 26/10/2007 23:35
Thanks Paul.
Allen
Welcome to HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 (http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/)
