HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 - Powered by Discuz! Board

Subject: Please help to identify this bird. [Print This Page]

Author: cywong Time: 3/02/2009 00:56 Subject: Please help to identify this bird.

Would experienced birdwatchers please help to identify this bird?

Fung Yuen 01/02/09

Image Attachment: IMG_8890s.jpg (3/02/2009 00:56, 112.17 KB) / Download count 436
http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/attachment.php?aid=2970

Author: John Holmes Time: 3/02/2009 11:32 Subject: Seicercus Warbler at Fung Yuen

Lack of a wing-bar makes me think of Grey-crowned Warbler (S.tephrocephalus) or Plain-tailed Warbler (S.soror).

The "commonest" Seicercus warbler in Hong Kong is Bianchi's Warbler (Seicercus valentini)which usually shows a yellow wing-bar.

It is hard to be sure which species this is. Until recently, all the above were considered "races" of the same species.

Anyway, a rare bird and interesting record for people to discuss!

John

Author: hgeorge Time: 3/02/2009 12:31

Hi Cherry,

Woo, new bird for fung yuen! Thanks for your finding.
Where did you find it? Could you describe the location? Finding in bird flock?
The best bird for fung yuen in winter 08-09.

Agree with John, only Grey-crowned or Plain-tailed to be fit to this warbler.
However, do you have more photos on the head and the bill.

Thanks,
George

Author: cywong Time: 3/02/2009 22:43

Many thanks to John and George.

This is another photo of the bird but sorry that it still cannot show the head of the bird clearly.

There is a large fruiting tree at Fung Yuen and a lot of bulbuls and some thrushes feeding on it. From the area of this fruiting tree, there is a narrow path leading to a large area of grass. This warbler was found near the end of the narrow path, near the large area of grass.

Image Attachment: IMG_8889s.jpg (3/02/2009 22:43, 107.36 KB) / Download count 437
http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/attachment.php?aid=2976

Author: ajohn Time: 4/02/2009 10:17

Can White-spectacled be ruled out on these photos?

Welcome to HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 (http://hkbws.org.hk/BBS/)