Mandy,
Yes. The Eye Relief of the zoom gets worse as you zoom so you would have to zoom the camera lens a lot ( or move the camera closer ) to reduce the vignetting.
I wonder whether the DCA fixed would work on the zoom as it might allow you to get the lenses closer together. Maybe Bob could test this out?
The other alternative is to have someone cut down the DCA by about 5 mm. I haven't heard of anyone doing this but it would be interesting to try.
Could you let us know your Exif information and the distance and time of day you are taking your photos? Neil.