HKBWS Forum 香港觀鳥會討論區 » Bird Identification 雀鳥辨識 » Shrike ID

Shrike ID

wkcheng

HKBWS Members

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

UID: 876
Posts: 270
Digest: 0
Credits: 0
NickName: Keung
Online: 86 hours
Registered: 21/11/2008
Last login: 21/04/2023

Send P.M.
Buddy
Offline

1^# A A A Post at 20/04/2011 21:45 Show author

Shrike ID

2011.04.19
Tai Po

Grey back and no white spot on its wing!

Grey-backed Shrike?
Or variation of Long-tailed Shrike?

Please help.

TOP

Ronaldo

HKBWS Members

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

UID: 14167
Posts: 386
Digest: 0
Credits: 0
NickName
Online: 607 hours
Registered: 26/12/2010
Last login: 23/06/2016

Send P.M.
Buddy
Offline

2^# A A A Post at 20/04/2011 22:17 Show author

i don't see why long-tailed would necessarily have a white patch on the wing. the dusky dark morph doesn't and there are frequent intermediate variations.

TOP

EricB

HKBWS Members

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

UID: 12770
Posts: 126
Digest: 0
Credits: 0
NickName
Online: 134 hours
Registered: 11/11/2010
Last login: 19/05/2017

Send P.M.
Buddy
Offline

3^# A A A Post at 22/04/2011 20:41 Show author

Grey backed Shrike has a brown tail(not black) and doesn't have any rufous on the mantle.
E

TOP

wkcheng

HKBWS Members

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

UID: 876
Posts: 270
Digest: 0
Credits: 0
NickName: Keung
Online: 86 hours
Registered: 21/11/2008
Last login: 21/04/2023

Send P.M.
Buddy
Offline

4^# A A A Post at 23/04/2011 20:34 Show author

Quote:

Original posted by RUWright at 22/04/2011 20:41
Grey backed Shrike has a brown tail(not black) and doesn't have any rufous on the mantle.
E

Thanks RWUright for detail explanation.

TOP

‹‹ Last Topic | Next Topic ››