iherman

Po Toi Island 蒲台島
14-4-2013

Please help to id if it is not the Greenish Warbler, thank you !!!
[img]A25IMG_6041a by bird8888, 於 Flickr[/img]

[img]A25IMG_6037a by bird8888, 於 Flickr[/img]

[img]A25IMG_6039a by bird8888, 於 Flickr[/img]

[ Last edited by iherman at 2/01/2018 23:49 ]

Jonathmartinez

it looks like a very  worn Yellow-browed Warbler.

All the best,

Jonathan

iherman

Thank you Jonathan

ltsunpun

我不認為是黃眉柳鶯 (yellow browed warbler)，因牠的三級飛羽並沒有淡色邊緣 (i.e. no plae edges to tertials)。
以我對柳鶯的有限知識，我會選極北柳鶯 (artic warbler), 因為牠第二條翼帶不太明顯，摺合的翼有淡色邊緣，而旦四月及五月也會有可能出現。 tpluk

wgeoff

Could it be a Hume's Leaf Warbler?

ajohn

Bare part colours and greenish tones to mantle support Yellow-browed Warbler rather than Hume's.

iherman

I found it size is bigger than Yellow-Browed Warbler

ajohn

Size can be deceptive and difficult to judge in the field. The plumage features point to Yellow-browed - pale fringes to tertials (albeit very worn) and dark base to secondaries. These features rule out other Phylloscopus, such as Greenish or Arctic Warblers