Thread
Print

dark-sided vs grey streaked flycatcher

dark-sided vs grey streaked flycatcher

Is there an easy way to tell if this is a grey-streaked or a dark-sided flycatcher?  Lamma cable road October 7th 2015


[ Last edited by sgeoff at 7/10/2015 11:38 ]
who sit and watch...

TOP

On first glance, it looks like dark-sided.  But after adjusting the exposure of the photo, it looks like an immature grey-streaked.
Interesting.  Would like to hear from the experts.

[ Last edited by irsychan at 8/10/2015 08:43 ]

TOP

It looks like a juvenile Dark-sided to me.
- The underparts appear to be mottled with dark, rather than showing defined streaks
- The bill looks relatively short, and mostly dark
- The eye-ring broadens behind the eye
- White spots on the upperparts are remaining juvenile plumage. Dark-sided are most often seen in Hong Kong as juveniles, whereas juvenile Grey-streaked seems to be less common (most presumably moult before migrating).

Compare these two juvenile/first winter birds:
Dark-sided: http://orientalbirdimages.org/se ... ize=1&Location=
Grey-streaked: http://orientalbirdimages.org/se ... ize=1&Location=

For me, Grey-streaked usually looks somehow larger and more powerful compared to similar flycatchers, whereas Dark-sided somehow seems a little smaller and more delicate.

TOP

That was my feeling for similar reasons but I don't have experience of this species so it's nice to have some confirmation from others who have more knowledge of the species in question.  Many thanks.
who sit and watch...

TOP

Quote:
Original posted by ajohn at 8/10/2015 15:18
It looks like a juvenile Dark-sided to me.
- The underparts appear to be mottled with dark, rather than showing defined streaks
- The bill looks relatively short, and mostly dark
- The eye-ring broad ...
I agree with your excellent assessment that this is a first-winter Dark-sided flycatcher.  I just found a paper entitled "Brown, Siberian and Grey-streaked Flycatchers: identification and ageing" by Paul J. Leader (British Birds 103. November 2010), which gives detailed discussion on the differences between Asian Brown, Dark-sided and Grey-streaked, covering both adults and juveniles.  The section on 'Wing shape and primary projection' and Fig. 2 are particularly helpful in further supporting that this is Dark-sided.

TOP

Thanks for the reference - it's also free to download, so that's a great resource.
who sit and watch...

TOP

Thread