puppymic

Tai Po Kau 30/12/2007

Thanks for watching  

puppymic

Could someone please help me to verify whether this bird is a Asian Brown Flycatcher or Red-Breasted Flycatcher. Thanks  

puppymic

Please  

puppymic

kmatthew

Looks like Asian Brown to me.

gary

It's a Asian Brown Flycatcher.

Gary

puppymic

Thank you Matthew and Gary.

Other opinion said (1) the eye sizes are not as big as those of the Asian Brown Flycatcher (2) the brid has slighter color in the breast

Whether it would possible be a red-breasted?

http://www.hkbws.org.hk/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=3599

Thanks
Mandy

Starshing

Actually the critical feature to tell red-breasted from Asian brown is the tail with 2 white spots on both upper tail for red-breasted, while asian brown without the spots.

Shing

puppymic

Thank you Shing.

I only have this photo, so sorry that I could not view its upper tail.