HFCheung

Well done!  I am glad that somebody have the chance of checking it themselves.

This incidence remind me of the same old question of keeping the site of important birds secret.  I am not insisting how this should be done one way or the other.  I am saying that we should have a uniform scale for ourselves and others.  If we want to keep this secret, then I think we better not blame others not to reveal their own secret sites.

HF Cheung

HFCheung

According to the criteria given by Paul, on this bird the tail is too round, the primary projection is not long, and also the flank is not enough white.  I would go for Brown Shrike.

HF Cheung